Upstate by Kim van Alkemade (Historical Fiction)

Plot: 5/5 Characters: 4/5 Writing: 3.5/5

It is 2021 and Audrey Beacon has escaped to the Adirondacks — buying a house and a somewhat derelict barn based book store in a desperate play to get away from New York City, Covid, and the devastating death of her young husband, alone in a hospital ward. We watch as she makes her (woefully unprepared) way in an isolated, rural, and fairly republican community (about which she has some strong concerns!). Paralleling her own journey through grief and toward self sufficiency are two interspersed narratives: a set of magazine articles written by Evelyn, the previous property owner ranging from 1960 to 1983; and a set of letters written to Evelyn by her longtime lover, Hazel, as Evelyn sinks into dementia (simultaneously telling us their story). The lines between these narratives start blending together into a very satisfying conclusion towards the end.

It is an emotional tale with strong themes of alienation, loneliness, and the kind of family and social dysfunction that arises from not fitting into an expected mold. Rejection based on a person’s ethnicity, sexual orientation, or as a result of suicide born of despair all come into play during the dramatic recounting and connecting of several life stories in this absorbing book. I was never bored and finished in just a few sittings. While the primary narrative follows Audrey in her current day search for meaning, the real heart of the story (IMHO) is the love story between Evelyn and Hazel — occurring at a time and place where lesbian love was by no means an accepted practice. Their story also encompassed some very frustrating facts about what women were and were not allowed to do period. Sometimes it’s hard (for me) to remember what actual laws, norms, and policies restricted women from doing pretty normal things such as holding positions of authority, working while pregnant, or getting a mortgage without a husband.

Great storytelling, decent writing, good characterization — although to be honest, I found I didn’t actually like some of the main characters very much, finding their behavior less than exemplary even with a description as to their probable motives. Still, very enjoyable read and you might relate to the characters more than I do!

Quote: “No wonder humans are storytelling animals, I think. Our lives are little more than an infinite series of random collisions. We need narrative to corral the shapeless stream of chance into a navigable river.”

Thank you to William Morrow Paperbacks and NetGalley for providing an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. The book was published on October 27th, 2027.

Miss Wolcott’s Ghost by Louise Penny (Mystery)

Loved this latest installment of Penny’s Inspector Gamache series. It returns the series to the kind of mystery stories that I love — individually intriguing cases, rather than high stakes terrorism, deeply corrupt institutions, or world shattering events. And the always cherished Three Pines with its idyllic existence (despite the prevalence of tricky murder cases!)

This story is launched with a mysterious middle of the night phone call from a wispy, yet somehow familiar voice. There is a body in the Lost Nation — an area few have heard of. The body leads to an investigation that reaches back through history to the sinking of the RMS Empress of Ireland — the 1914 maritime disaster that took the lives of over 1,000 people. In a typically (for Penny) convoluted set of plot lines, a very strange plant, long thought to be extinct, is found literally growing out of the body.

This is Penny at her best. Excellent crime writing with perfect pacing, full of psychological and philosophical themes, and multiple threads weaving throughout leading sometimes to closure and other times into (literal and figurative) weeds. Our favorite characters return — everyone in Three Pines is the best at what they do and it is fun to temporarily inhabit an environment full of competence and intellectual curiosity —an artist, an archivist, a baker, a psychologist / book store owner, and an nth degree crank of a Poet Laureate. The homicide squad characters are equally engaging — ideal, but somehow not idealized. Strong, competent, principled, but also reflective and aware of biases and flaws. And with Inspector Gamache, we are exposed to the fallibility of a Godlike hero — which makes a far more interesting detective than the old fashioned Hero archetype or the more modern, morally ambiguous, and deeply flawed protagonists.

It’s a complete page turner with plenty of depth about subjects you may not have ever considered but now find intriguing. Lots of little dopamine hits as you go. This episode epitomizes everything I like about my favorite Penny books: focused mystery, historical and cultural detail, characters I like to spend time with, and moments of poetic poignancy.

Somewhere, Something Incredible by Susan Meissner

I’m a big Susan Meissner fan — she writes deeply felt, concisely relevant, historical fiction spanning a wide variety of times, places, and cultural contexts. This book is set in the late 60s — a time of great upheaval, violence, idealism, disorder, and for many — despair. The story focusses on an aging parent (Lucille) who, after a fall and a brief coma, seems to have had a personality change. She is happier, but in her daughter Gwen’s eyes, more impulsive, vulnerable, and making bad decisions. One day she appears to have gone missing, in the company of a man that Gwen deeply distrusts.

The story bounces between the present and an episodic progression to the present, starting from nine months prior. Told from alternating perspectives — Gwen’s and granddaughter Natalie’s — it is a story full of hope in the face of disaster, self realization, and blundering about the border of responsibility, care, protection, and control — all with the best intentions!

Meissner brings to life both the historical context and the very real danger of misperceptions, misguided and / or misunderstood goals, and teasing apart the very difficult decisions around autonomy, rights, and abilities as one ages.

I loved this quote from the afterward:

“Who gets to decide what makes another person happy? Does there ever come a point as we age when someone else needs to decide what we’re allowed to enjoy? At what juncture should an adult child intervene when an aging parent begins to make what appear to be unwise choices?”

Thank you to Berkley and NetGalley for providing an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. The book will be published on February 9th, 2027.

The Queen of Roses by Julia Kelly (Historical Fiction)

.Julia Kelly writes beautiful historical fiction, encompassing story with a personal immersion in the social and physical context of the times. This novel brings to life Pasadena in the early 1900s through dual timelines: one following Adele — an English rose imported from England against her inclination in 1903 — and Theresa — a woman journalist trying to break away from the dead-end (pun intended!) obit desk in 1960. An opportunity to interview a reclusive “old lady” living out of town in a gorgeous rose nursery may be the break she is looking for. Pasadena (as we all know after the recent fire) is fire country, and fire plays a role in both timelines.

I love Kelly’s writing — she’s a “show not tell” writer so all of the detailed and gorgeous prose describing life, surroundings, manners, and society comes naturally as part of the story. There are no long, dreary (to me) descriptions of wainscoting, tableware, or dress tufts that I am forced to skim through, and yet I can picture the houses, the grounds, and the clothing with ease. And the ambiance of the place at that time — the openness, the newness, the literal feel of opportunity and space — are incredibly real. I happened to be reading this while in a nearby section of Los Angeles — definitely a stark contrast! The pace is slow, and yet never boring. Just the right amount of words used to smoothly carry you from start to finish. Never choppy. I forgot that I was reading. Plenty of story with a satisfying conclusion. Gardening — in a way appealing (I think) to even non gardeners.

Very enjoyable.

Thank you to Gallery Books and NetGalley for providing an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. The book was published on October 20th, 2026.

As you Wake, Break the Shell by Becky Chambers (Science Fiction)

A love story in a somewhat (but not completely) dystopic world with fantastic (literally) world building, deep characterization, plenty of action, and utterly absorbing (to me) philosophical meanderings into the nature of life, consciousness, connection, and alien (both literal and figurative) understanding.

Cora is a rorqual pilot — and the depiction of the rorqual “species” and Colibri — the specific rorqual connected to Cora — is worth the whole price of admission. My favorite aspect of science fiction — and Chambers has always excelled at this — is exposing us to new kinds of beings: the way they work, the way they interact, and the way both individual and group level relationships with them function. Signy is a botanist who illegally designs and prints medicines that aren’t necessarily approved for those she helps. Their love story — a beautiful one told in two converging timelines before and after an event — is really the primary point of the story. But the substrate of the story — a world, a system, a set of restrictions, a wiggly compliancy, competing desires, and most of all connection — is magnificent. And I really, really loved the scenes with Colibri in them.

It could have been a little shorter in my opinion, but I have to admit that I was entranced reading about life in this very different world under very different expectations. Unlike her Monk and Robot series, only one or two minor characters use the “they” pronoun so I’m (happily) able to read the whole book without undue cognitive stress for which I’m quite grateful!

Looking forward to book two!

Go Gentle by Maria Semple (Literary Fiction)

An absolute pleasure to read from start to finish!

Adora Hazzard — one-time comedy writer turned staff philosopher for precocious (and wealthy) twins on the Upper West Side. Lover of the Stoics. Instigator of a modern day coven (not what you think but even better!). And … an unwitting participant in the convoluted slip ’n slide of an art heist / Interpol / spy ring adventure. It’s funny how I can ignore the “plot” almost completely in favor of the deep dive into Adora’s character— her development of a personal life philosophy (with well-educated underpinnings), her eventual reckoning with poor past decisions, and her somewhat herky jerky reaction to the possibility of … love.

I give the writing an A+++. Fast paced, witty, infused with exceptional banter and a razor sharp clarity of thought applied to complex topics. Full of intriguing characters (in addition to Adora) — all memorable in their own way based not on who they are but on what they think, say, and make happen. I LOVED the injection of philosophy from the ancients to the current times — all made accessible and applicable to everyday life. I’ve read a lot of philosophy (admittedly a few decades ago) but I enjoyed thinking some new (to me) thoughts and puzzling out how what I learned might apply to my life. I’m a sucker for questions of moral rectitude and applied ethics and those were plentifully supplied. I also loved the various relationship reflections, shifts, and the way Semple depicted discussions on volatile topics with a subtle recognition of when ideology or a simple lack of thought snuck in and how the relationship changed (suffered?) as a result.

In summary — loved this book! Made me laugh, made me think, made me reflect, and it was fun to read. Can’t ask for much more than that! Some people took a real dislike to Adora, applying some pretty interesting judgements to her character (we have, as a culture, become so over-the-top judgmental IMHO). I think I could take up a whole book club discussion on the whys of that one. For my part, I’m a big fan.

Just a few quotes that don’t give too much away — there are great ones on every page:

“Inside her apartment, Matt (shoes-on, doing the couch luge) was gunning people down with an intensity I reckoned he never applied to learning her love language. A statement bong dominated the coffee table. Meanwhile, out in the hallway, bag handles had begun to cut off circulation to his beloved’s ringless fingers.”

“An unimpeachably intentional, highly curated, feminist old folks’ home? Nah, not much of a ring. A tragic, estrogen-free trio trying to put our best face on the realization society is done with us and we’re destined to die alone? No, and bite your tongue.”

“I adored learning about the personal lives of the philosophers and tracking the progression of collective thought throughout history. How every breakthrough idea had been a

Profits, Prophets, Coaches, and Kings by Jared Diamond (popular science / history)

I never read the very popular Guns, Germs, and Steel, so perhaps my expectations for this book were too high, but I did find it disappointing. The subject was ostensibly “When do leaders matter” — is there something uniquely capable about them or are they just in the right place at the right time and someone else would have accomplished the same thing had they not been there. To expand on this “query” Diamond elaborates (at length and in a rambling, unclear, and far too repetitive manner) on the “research” methods used to investigate the question: biography, the “Hamlet test,” and natural experiments (finding experimental situations “in the wild” rather than planned in laboratory).

The book is segmented into four categories: Political, business, sports, and religious leaders. I did enjoy many of the “stories” — mini biographies of “great” figures in each category, and some high level, but interesting analysis of why some religions succeeded while others did not (surprisingly Islam was not mentioned which is a bit of an oversight? Perhaps intentional?). However, I found the depth of investigation to be shallow to the point where I felt some recaps came straight from wikipedia without checking for factual inaccuracies (of which I found several), and conclusions drawn in a sloppy fashion without adequate coverage of contributing factors or even breadth of contributing research.

The writing is (IMHO) simply bad. The narrative rambles, repeats, inserts some personal stories that were strangely ineffective at bonding us to the writer. A large number of pages are devoted to explaining various research techniques but I did not find the writing to have the clarity I look for when explaining potentially complex or unfamiliar subjects. I’m already familiar with these techniques but I wouldn’t have understood them from his verbose and incoherent descriptions. I was also a bit disturbed in some places by his content — asking his readers “do they feel strongly enough about an individual leader’s negative impact that they would sacrifice their own life in order to assassinate him or her?” He was referring to Hitler but too many people today are taking that question seriously and considering “evil” targets that have done little more than disagree with their ideology. Do we want to suggest to people that assassination is a noble endeavor as that question suggests? Similarly, he lumped Margaret Thatcher and Mao Zedong together into a category of leaders with a “mixed legacy.” Mao killed 40 – 80 million of his own people. Does Margaret Thatcher really fall into the same category? Small points but troubling nonetheless.

The book is really a set of vignettes loosely aligned with leadership and impact. I found it entertaining at times, though more difficult to read than it should have been. I didn’t find the main question to be an important one, nor do I think he actually came to any real conclusion, never mind one based on real data extracted from solid research methods. I would categorize this in the popular science / history category along with Mary Roach, Malcolm Gladwell and their ilk, though less entertaining.

Thank you to Mariner Books and NetGalley for providing an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. The book was published on September 1st, 2026.

Monsters of Ohio by John Scalzi

Another wacky (and every-page humorous) story from John Scalzi. I love that every Scalzi story that I read reminds me of … absolutely no other story I’ve read. Unique, fun, and — regardless of the weirdness (and sometimes grossness) — pretty upbeat! I bet Scalzi doesn’t even have to work hard on this stuff — I think his tall tales come tumbling out of his brain already perfectly formed.

The setting — a small town in Ohio, a greedy corporation ready to extract every resource before tossing the remainders away, an even sleazier representative of said corp looking to further line his own pockets with some friendly embezzlement on the side. One thing about Scalzi’s books — it’s always very clear who the good guys are and who the bad guys are. Enter our hero, the wry, competent, guy-you-want-on-a-desert-island Mike Boyd — freshly “released” from a D.C. job in the USDA, coming “home,” tail between legs to an emotional set of townies. And then things start to get weird in the way only Scalzi tales can get. Check out the book cover for a few hints. Reminds me of old Astounding magazine covers…

A couple of extra points. Loved the first chapter which is told in second person from the perspective of … a rabbit. Hysterical. Could not stop laughing but also completely engrossed in the rabbit’s experience! Also — cryptids — have not heard that word before but I like it and it has high relevance. Look it up!

Fun, easy to read, a great reality-based hero, and did I mention weird? Really stimulates the creative centers and the funny bone.

Thank you to Tor Books and NetGalley for providing an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. The book will be published on November 3rd, 2026.

The American Way of Killing by Malcolm Gladwell (Non fiction)

Gladwell’s latest tackles the highly emotional topic of Violence in America — and he tackles it with a shocking amount of anger and aggression aimed at Americans — all 350 million of us. Gladwell’s general approach to his subjects is to (in his words) find interesting anecdotes and interesting research and pair them up. The set of vignettes in this collection do this but in a hostile and often misleading way. Hostile in that he’s clearly angry at Americans (again — all of us) literally and repeatedly calling us stupid, dishonest, “morally reckless,” and pedantic at various points in the narratives. Misleading in that none of his “stories” are comprehensive — some offer partial (but never tested at scale) solutions, many describe efforts and explain why they are a waste of time, a few contradict each other, and several leave out critical aspects of the data that could change the conclusions. I am glad I read this book and I did learn some new and relevant information, but I strongly recommend reading the book critically and doing your own supplemental research to get a fuller picture.

The bits I found interesting: Americans (according to Gladwell) think they are over policed, but in fact we are largely under-policed. A comparison of police forces in L.A. and Berlin (equal populations with L.A. a larger physical area) surprised me. 8,500 police in L.A. vs 18,000 in Berlin. This section included a good description of how a larger police force could prevent more crime and improve community engagement based on interviews with those who had run large police forces (e.g. Boston, L.A.). A dive into a program to teach young men (the victims and perpetrators of the largest segment of gun violence) how to maintain emotional control based on the “realization” that much of gun violence was based on “an exaggerated sense of moral injury leading them to take the law into their on hands.” A few dips into how gun fatality statistics are influenced on the one hand by the amazing abilities of surgeons to save victims who would have died in the past, and on the other hand by the location of trauma centers which are often not close enough to the areas that need them the most. While not productive in any sense, I did learn something from the details of the assault weapons ban — pages and pages of specific weapons banned, an even longer list of those not banned, followed by his point that most homicides were committed with handguns anyway.

The pointless or frustrating bits: Long diatribes about our “absurd” focus on the second amendment and the pedantic nature of the Supreme Court, betraying incomprehension for what the Constitution is and how the Supreme Court is supposed to make decisions (Gladwell is a British-Canadian who has lived in the U.S. since the mid eighties without applying for citizenship so maybe he missed the memo?). Conflating homicides and suicides into single gun violence statistics which give misleading ideas about where the biggest problems are. Some sideways mentions of racism without any cohesive theme — almost as though just throwing it in there.

I’ve read most, if not all, of Gladwell’s books and have enjoyed them. They are called “pop sociology” and I enjoy the surprising tidbits. However, with such a critical topic under discussion, the light-weight nature of the anecdotes coupled with the needlessly hostile tone really didn’t work for me. Read it — but spend some time thinking about what you read and maybe do a little extra research before drawing any conclusions.

There are so many good sources of relevant information out there. Here are a few statistics that I found (and found easily): There is an oft referenced meme on gun friendly states having the highest amount of gun deaths. Using the CDC data at https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/state-stats/deaths/homicide.html, what I found is that by removing the suicides and only looking at homicides, many of the “red” states known to be very gun friendly (Montana, Wyoming, Alaska) jumped down to the middle of the list because almost all (80-90%) of their gun deaths were suicides. In fact, California (very blue!) and Montana (pretty red!) have the exact same number of homicide gun deaths per capita. I also looked up what percentage of firearms in the U.S. were used to cause injury or fatality — according to https://publichealth.jhu.edu/center-for-gun-violence-solutions/data/annual-gun-violence-data, this is 0.003% of all firearms. Lastly, I asked one of the AI engines to give me information on guns used in self-defense and it gave me pointers to several different surveys run by a variety of organizations resulting in a large range (70,000 – 2,500,000) of reported self-defense events, mostly guns used as a deterrant, i.e. without firing a shot. For me this helps to frame why so many people want guns and how few (and concentrated) the use of guns for violence is.

I should mention that I am by no means a “gun nut,” and I’m extremely worried about the level of overall violence in our country — not just inner city gun homicides, but the tendency towards violence with any kind of weapon, the acceptance of politically motivated violence, the excusing of violence committed by the mentally ill, and the violence committed by people who just seem to enjoy it. Some level of gun control is of course required, but it is in no way sufficient. We have a big problem with people and culture — some of Gladwell’s stories point in the right direction, but not nearly enough.

Thank you to Little, Brown and Company and NetGalley for providing an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. The book will be published on September 29th, 2027.

Peck & Peck by Bonnie Garmus (Literary Fiction)

At heart, this is a novel about poetry and how it can change your life — but the poetry theme is tightly inserted into a narrative populated by a madcap scramble of an adventure story replete with good vs evil, multiple layers of deception, the best kind of quirky characters, and lots of personal confusion (and eventual growth :-)) You can read it for the plot, the twisty characters, and / or for the opportunity to do some pretty deep thinking.

Our narrator is Batter — a somewhat timid character who falls hard for Poetry despite experimenting with a wide variety of majors that might have led to more lucrative careers (he does surprisingly well in Accounting). He recognizes that he hasn’t the talent to be a Poet himself, but decides he wants to discover Poets — like Brian Epstein discovered the Beatles. When he heads to the Big Apple after graduation nobody (but himself) is pleased, but through an interesting set of happenstances he lands a (very) low level job at Peck & Peck — the highly illustrious and beyond upscale (also incredibly expensive) Poetry journal. That’s when things start to get interesting.

I’m a character person, and the characters in this book are so very captivating. It took me awhile to warm up to Batter whose timidity and lack of self confidence or direction I found irritating, but I fell in love with his mother immediately. If you’re looking for an Elizabeth Zott type figure, Rainey is it. Rainey is a typeface designer and even if you haven’t a smidgen of interest in the characteristics of typefaces (e.g. common fonts like Arial, Times New Roman, or Palatino or unusual ones such as Impact, Baskerville, Caslon), you might well find her mini contextual lectures on the practical and emotional factors of typeface choice fascinating — I know I did. Dad is the “interesting” kind of historian — one who examines not just what happened in the past, but how the narration shifts with the teller, and how easily we can all be bamboozled. Every one of the editors at Peck & Peck have their own idiosyncratic set of motivations, cringes, hopes, and driving instincts that keep you on your toes if you happen to get bored. And then there is Batter’s “love at first sight” interest… Every character is a real obsessive type — but that’s what makes them interesting (and almost every one of the obsessions is completely obsession-worthy!)

But what about Poetry as a strong theme? I’ve never been a big fan, despite my voracious reading habits. But I perked up when I read one poetry-passionate character toss off the fact that 95% of poetry is boring. Yes! But his thesis is that the very top 1/2% is life changing. This book included excellent pointers to some spectacular poetry and surprisingly I have compiled a set of them and am happily reading, tearing (as in crying, not ripping) up as appropriate.

So — overall fun to read, some very interesting philosophical questions to ponder, a whole lot of tangent topics that were either completely new to me or offered new depths to what I thought I knew already — such as typeface design, slam poetry sessions, and … have you ever heard of heteropaternal superfecundation? Look it up! Reminded me of John Irving books in the way all the weird tangents actually come together in the end to achieve something. A good read.

Quotes:
“Poetry provides answers and despite what my pre-law classes would call an appalling lack of evidence, their answers always seemed right. Or something even more unlikely. Truthful.”

“Awful people succeed because nice people let them. This is the drawback of being nice. Nice people worry that it isn’t nice to take action against awful people because they don’t want to act awful themselves – they don’t want to stoop to that level. But I think nice people have been stooping all along. The worst kind of stooping – because it isn’t stooping, it’s bending over.”

“Poetry is problematic. First, it’s not easy. It forces you to think and sometimes thinking hurts. Also, poetry can make you feel stupid, like you don’t get it. And if you do get it, then it’s only because it just revealed something about yourself that you were hoping to keep hidden.”

“That, in a nutshell, is how the brothers gained new readership: by showing normal, everyday people what poetry was really all about. How it could make them feel; what it could make them think; and why it could change their lives — not just for one night, but for every night thereafter.”

“Dickinson once wrote that hope is a thing with feathers. If that’s true, despair must be a pair of concrete shoes. I know because I wore mine home.”

“The poets I publish have the nerve, the audacity, to face life’s struggles. To wrestle with ugliness, to question prevailing wisdom, to grasp at beauty. And they do it, not by mimicking what’s already been done — not by tilling the same ground, not by planting the same crop, not by sowing the same harvest — but by starting fresh. In a world devoid of poets, do you know what you get? Another knockoff. Another mouthwash.”

“Humans thrive on constant renewal. We require fresh ideas and original thinking to survive, and yet it sometimes feels like the art and necessity of thinking is becoming passe; that the one-size-fits-most, sitcom-rich, knockoff lifestyle is winning. I confess that some days I find the passivity of the human race overwhelming.”

“Since you’re a poetry lover, maybe you’ve heard of this new thing that makes poetry tolerable. It’s called music.”

Thank you to Scribner and NetGalley for providing an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. The book will be published on October 13th, 2027.