Upstate by Kim van Alkemade (Historical Fiction)

Plot: 5/5 Characters: 4/5 Writing: 3.5/5

It is 2021 and Audrey Beacon has escaped to the Adirondacks — buying a house and a somewhat derelict barn based book store in a desperate play to get away from New York City, Covid, and the devastating death of her young husband, alone in a hospital ward. We watch as she makes her (woefully unprepared) way in an isolated, rural, and fairly republican community (about which she has some strong concerns!). Paralleling her own journey through grief and toward self sufficiency are two interspersed narratives: a set of magazine articles written by Evelyn, the previous property owner ranging from 1960 to 1983; and a set of letters written to Evelyn by her longtime lover, Hazel, as Evelyn sinks into dementia (simultaneously telling us their story). The lines between these narratives start blending together into a very satisfying conclusion towards the end.

It is an emotional tale with strong themes of alienation, loneliness, and the kind of family and social dysfunction that arises from not fitting into an expected mold. Rejection based on a person’s ethnicity, sexual orientation, or as a result of suicide born of despair all come into play during the dramatic recounting and connecting of several life stories in this absorbing book. I was never bored and finished in just a few sittings. While the primary narrative follows Audrey in her current day search for meaning, the real heart of the story (IMHO) is the love story between Evelyn and Hazel — occurring at a time and place where lesbian love was by no means an accepted practice. Their story also encompassed some very frustrating facts about what women were and were not allowed to do period. Sometimes it’s hard (for me) to remember what actual laws, norms, and policies restricted women from doing pretty normal things such as holding positions of authority, working while pregnant, or getting a mortgage without a husband.

Great storytelling, decent writing, good characterization — although to be honest, I found I didn’t actually like some of the main characters very much, finding their behavior less than exemplary even with a description as to their probable motives. Still, very enjoyable read and you might relate to the characters more than I do!

Quote: “No wonder humans are storytelling animals, I think. Our lives are little more than an infinite series of random collisions. We need narrative to corral the shapeless stream of chance into a navigable river.”

Thank you to William Morrow Paperbacks and NetGalley for providing an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. The book was published on October 27th, 2027.

Leave a Reply