Miss Wolcott’s Ghost by Louise Penny (Mystery)

Loved this latest installment of Penny’s Inspector Gamache series. It returns the series to the kind of mystery stories that I love — individually intriguing cases, rather than high stakes terrorism, deeply corrupt institutions, or world shattering events. And the always cherished Three Pines with its idyllic existence (despite the prevalence of tricky murder cases!)

This story is launched with a mysterious middle of the night phone call from a wispy, yet somehow familiar voice. There is a body in the Lost Nation — an area few have heard of. The body leads to an investigation that reaches back through history to the sinking of the RMS Empress of Ireland — the 1914 maritime disaster that took the lives of over 1,000 people. In a typically (for Penny) convoluted set of plot lines, a very strange plant, long thought to be extinct, is found literally growing out of the body.

This is Penny at her best. Excellent crime writing with perfect pacing, full of psychological and philosophical themes, and multiple threads weaving throughout leading sometimes to closure and other times into (literal and figurative) weeds. Our favorite characters return — everyone in Three Pines is the best at what they do and it is fun to temporarily inhabit an environment full of competence and intellectual curiosity —an artist, an archivist, a baker, a psychologist / book store owner, and an nth degree crank of a Poet Laureate. The homicide squad characters are equally engaging — ideal, but somehow not idealized. Strong, competent, principled, but also reflective and aware of biases and flaws. And with Inspector Gamache, we are exposed to the fallibility of a Godlike hero — which makes a far more interesting detective than the old fashioned Hero archetype or the more modern, morally ambiguous, and deeply flawed protagonists.

It’s a complete page turner with plenty of depth about subjects you may not have ever considered but now find intriguing. Lots of little dopamine hits as you go. This episode epitomizes everything I like about my favorite Penny books: focused mystery, historical and cultural detail, characters I like to spend time with, and moments of poetic poignancy.

Leave a Reply